Security Challenges in a Globalizing World (8921M009)
All documents for this subject (10)
Seller
Follow
giacomoef
Reviews received
Content preview
Notes on the lectures from the course (2024) Security Challenges in a Globalizing World. INCLUDES
notes from lectures 1-7 (Total: 19 ages).
Security Challenges in a Globalizing World Lecture Notes (Lectures
1-7)
Table of Contents
Lecture 1: Introduction 1
Lecture 2: Polycrisis, Anxiety & Ontological (In)Security in International Relations 4
Lecture 3: Threats, Narrative, Routines - Acting in an Anxious International 8
Lecture 4: Identity Politics 12
Lecture 5: Modern Anti-Institutional Extremism, Populism & the Crisis of Liberal
Democracy 14
Lecture 6: Conspiracy Theories - Battle for the Truth 16
, 1
Lecture 1: Introduction
Introduction: The Concept of Ontological (In)Security
Ontological Security: A lens or protected bubble of unreality, that helps us focus on the big picture.
We share confidence & trust in the world, with a sense of continuity that this will carry on.
➔ It does NOT refer to ‘classic’ security (e.g., physical danger, survival, war).
◆ Mitzen = “security NOT of the body but of the Self, the subjective sense of who one is,
which enables and motivates action and choice.”
◆ Giddens = people’s ability to give meaning (associated with positive/stable
emotions) to their lives, while avoiding chaos & anxiety.
➔ This concept is a lens/perspective (NOT an all-explaining theory).
◆ Relates to individual perceptions as influenced by major societal transformations &
political narratives.
➔ Necessary factors to feel ontologically secure:
1. Stable sense of home.
2. Feeling that nature is benign (NOT out to get us).
3. Sense that our contract with society, institutions & the government are NOT harmful
(preferably positive).
➔ Catastrophes can threaten our ontological security & ‘pierce’ our bubble. This can further
undermine the foundational degree of security of the ongoing control & predictability within
our daily lives.
➔ Important conditions = stable sense of:
◆ Stability: Freedom of anxiety about what may happen next.
● Security as a low probability of damage to acquired values.
● Most people want tomorrow to be more or less the same as today.
◆ Continuity & order = gives meaning to our lives, that the world is a stable & safe
place, predictable & generally positive.
◆ Trust & continuity = if we have to check everything for possible risk & danger all the
time, we will be anxious all the time
◆ Stable sense of home = community, nationhood, national identity or the notion that
society is a safe place for everyone.
◆ Sense of contract with society = among our fellow citizens, leaders & institutions.
➔ Dialectical approach = the concept of ontological security enables the analysis of the impact
of major social transformations on communities & individuals.
◆ Focuses on dynamic & developing moments (why & how things happen).
Ontological Insecurity: Disorienting & destabilising Other of ontological security (i.e., distrust,
anxieties, risk, danger, fear).
➔ When faced with this, people attempt to restore ontological security (from mode to more
extreme attempts).
➔ Mechanisms can include boundary-making & othering (difference between ‘us’ & ‘them’)
that create a sense of home.
Why is ontological (in)security a focus of this course?
, 2
● Enable a multilevel perspective (e.g., individual, community nation, states, international
system).
Perspectives on ontological security:
I. Laing’s The Divided Self (1960): Psychoanalytical approach examining existential anxieties.
Connecting the individual’s mental well being to society.
➔ Critical approach = the patient’s behaviour does NOT reflect a mental disease, BUT is
expressive of their existence.
II. Giddens’ Sociological Approach: Examined how societal structures impact ontological
security. Highlights the importance of people’s embedded:
➔ Social Narratives: People need a story about the society they are living in, how they
relate to it, expectations of them & others.
➔ Routines: Enabling people to live their life in a stable & more or less predictable way.
III. Kinnvall = religion & nationalism are powerful responses to insecurity & existential
anxieties. They work as identity-signifiers promising security & stability.
➔ Identity = anxiety-controlling mechanism (grants a consistent structure).
➔ Nationalism & nostalgia = mechanisms going back to an imagined past in response
to globalisation’s disruptive patterns (recreates a lost sense of security).
➔ Globalisation = migratory patterns lead to a breakdown of people’s identities.
IV. Browning = Brexit through the lens of ontological security (“take back control”).
➔ Mirrored feeling of crisis & instability = an existential anxiety.
➔ Key enemies:
◆ Brussels (the threatening Other) = threatening sovereignty, national identity
& the very essence of the UK
◆ Migration = taking back control over the borders.
The Precariat (Guy Standing): Disruptions in economic continuity & a lack of work-based identity has
created a new class of people with justified anger. This class is defined by 3 dimensions:
1. NO ‘shadow of the future’ (a sense that what you do will have a long-term effect). Highlights
the importance of routines.
2. NO occupational narrative, constantly faced with uncertainty (unsure what to do with your
time) & unsustainable debt.
3. NO political representation = loss of civil, economic & political rights.
Resistance Identities (Castells): 1990s prediction of the rise in justified anger & anxieties associated
with globalisation. Types:
1. Nationalist Movements: 1990s celebrated the idea of a Global Village (1990s), where nation
states were deemed to be dead & buried. HOWEVER, the age of globalisation has led to a
resurgence in nationalism & the reconstruction of identity based on nationality.
2. Fundamentalist Movements: Push to restore older ‘fundamental’ values, truths & practices.
Switching themselves off the global networks (splendid isolation).
3. Alternative Movements: Oppose the current codes/logic of globalised late modernity,
sometimes fighting/escaping the system or building alternative/parallel societies.
➔ Includes ecological, feminist & human rights movements.
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller giacomoef. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $7.61. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
